Federal finances: Capital positive aspects tax, extra might goal high-income earners

Article content material

We have now a date. Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland will ship Canada’s federal finances plan on March 28, giving us lower than two weeks to take a position about what might — or might not — be included therein, which additionally means time is working out to do any important planning earlier than any potential tax modifications.

Article content material

Nobody is aware of with any certainty what will probably be within the upcoming finances, however we are able to glean some perception on its potential themes from the 226-page pre-budget Report of the Standing Committee on Finance issued final week, which contained 230 separate suggestions for tax modifications and spending.

Article content material

Among the many proposals, the next advice might set the tone: “Undertake a public overview to determine federal tax expenditures, tax loopholes and different tax avoidance mechanisms that notably profit high-income people, rich people and huge firms and make suggestions to get rid of or restrict them.”

With that ominous theme in thoughts, listed below are some potential tax modifications that might goal higher-income Canadians, together with some potential planning suggestions.

Article content material

Prime tax bracket

The highest federal tax charge of 33 per cent at the moment kicks in at an revenue of greater than $235,675 for 2023, which is a 6.3 per cent bump within the threshold over 2022 because of the excessive inflation we’ve been experiencing over the previous 12 months. The NDP’s pre-election platform hoped to extend the highest charge by two share factors to 35 per cent. If enacted, this might carry the highest mixed marginal tax charge, as soon as provincial tax is factored in, to roughly 56 per cent in British Columbia, Ontario, Quebec and Nova Scotia, and to 57 per cent in Newfoundland and Labrador.

The same proposal to bump up the highest charge for the best revenue earners was not too long ago included in United States President Joe Biden’s finances announcement earlier this month. He known as for a prime federal revenue tax charge of 39.6 per cent, up from 37 per cent, for taxpayers incomes greater than US$400,000.

Article content material

Article content material

Surplus strips

The federal government might determine to close down a well-liked personal company tax-planning association that some subtle taxpayers have been using to distribute company surplus (basically, retained earnings for tax functions) from their company at capital positive aspects charges, slightly than on the greater charges for Canadian dividends, or through the fee of a wage or bonus.

The Canada Income Company has beforehand tried to problem surplus strip transactions, however the courts have typically held that such a planning is suitable, and doesn’t violate the final anti-avoidance rule, because the Earnings Tax Act doesn’t include a normal coverage requiring shareholders to take away their surplus through a dividend slightly than a capital acquire.

Article content material

The federal government tried to close down such a planning as a part of its personal company tax reforms in 2017, however these proposals had been finally deserted after important public criticism.

Different minimal tax

Final 12 months’s federal finances famous that “some high-income Canadians nonetheless pay comparatively little in private revenue tax as a share of their revenue.” To deal with this, the federal government introduced a proper overview of the choice minimal tax (AMT), the outcomes of which had been initially supposed to return out in final fall’s financial replace. As a substitute, the federal government acknowledged {that a} “detailed proposal and path for implementation” could be launched within the upcoming finances.

After all, we have already got a federal AMT at a 15-per-cent charge. The main the reason why some high-income Canadians pay low efficient charges of tax has nothing to do with nefarious tax planning. For probably the most half, high-income earners are doing nothing greater than claiming registered retirement financial savings plan deductions, charitable donations and dividend tax credit, and incomes half-taxable capital positive aspects.

Article content material

South of the border, Biden’s latest finances included a proposal to introduce a brand new 25-per-cent minimal tax on people whose internet price is greater than US$100 million. This new tax could be totally different, in that it will be imposed on each revenue and unrealized capital positive aspects for the wealthiest 0.01 per cent.

Capital positive aspects inclusion charge

Lastly, no dialogue of potential finances modifications could be full with out at the very least bearing on the capital positive aspects inclusion charge. At present set at 50 per cent, it’s possible you’ll recall that the NDP’s platform proposed a hike to 75 per cent.

In preparation for the finances discussions, Jonathan Rhys Kesselman, emeritus professor at Simon Fraser College’s Faculty of Public Coverage, simply launched a paper entitled Pathways to Reform of Capital Features Taxation in Canada that considers the case for growing taxes on capital positive aspects in Canada, and the implications for the upcoming reform of the AMT.

Article content material

Kesselman exhibits there’s a excessive focus of capital positive aspects amongst comparatively few taxpayers and at very excessive incomes, and means that concentrating on an elevated capital positive aspects inclusion charge, both on massive positive aspects above a sure greenback quantity or by filers with very excessive incomes, would sharply scale back the variety of affected taxpayers, “easing each administration and compliance in addition to public acceptance.”

Biden’s finances proposed an analogous measure. The U.S. at the moment taxes lengthy‐​time period capital positive aspects and dividends at a prime charge of 20 per cent federally, plus internet funding revenue tax (NIIT) of three.8 per cent. The U.S. finances proposed taxing capital positive aspects at a brand new prime marginal revenue tax charge of 39.6 per cent (plus elevating the NIIT to 5 per cent) for taxpayers with greater than US$1 million of annual revenue.

Article content material

If a change had been introduced to Canada’s capital positive aspects inclusion charge, it will possible be efficient as of finances day (March 28). This implies traders who worry a bump within the inclusion charge may take into account accelerating any planning, together with a possible rebalancing of their portfolios by taking positive aspects now, thereby locking in a 50-per-cent inclusion charge. There are additionally extra subtle tax methods that might purchase you a while when you’re not sure what may occur to the inclusion charge on finances day.

Jamie Golombek, CPA, CA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Personal Wealth in Toronto. Jamie.Golombek@cibc.com.

_____________________________________________________________

When you favored this story, join extra within the FP Investor publication.

_____________________________________________________________